Bethany produces National Merit Scholars at nearly 5 times the national average (national average is .275 per school per year or 2.7 students over ten years).

2012 None

2011 Taylor Ann Krahn

2010 Tony Miller

2009 Erin Helmuth and Elias Kehr

2008 None

2007 None

2006 None

2005 Paul Boers

2004 Jon Meyer

2003 David Glick, Justin Heinz

2002 Sarah Dick, Austin Scharf

2001 Jeff Claassen, Jed Wulliman

2000 Renee Glick, Andrew Histand, Aaron Lehman

1999 Alison Dick, Matt Fisher, Tim Nafziger

1998 Jennifer McFarlane

1997 Hannah Stutzman

1996 None

1995 Jason Lehman, Kelly Short

1994 None

1993 Matthew Miller, Kerry Stump

1992 Amy Kauffman, Nate Rempel

1991 Ryan Miller, Sam Miller, Paul Stauffer

1990 Cheryl Hochstetler, Lisa Stauffer, Mark Yoder

1989 Jon Kauffman, James Maust, Gretchen Nyce

1988 Steven Longenecker, David Schipani, Chris Stauffer, John Troyer

1987 Jeremy Kropf, Jenny Smeltzer, David Wert

1986 Mark Guengerich

1985 David Jeschke, Randy Newswanger

1984 Scott Mark, Greg Newswanger

1983 Peter Burkholder, Kelly Lerner, Jon Liechty, Elaine Moyer, Karl Steiner, Don Wert

1982 None

1981 Roger Kurtz

1980 Deb Augsburger, Kathy Hochstetler

1979 Linda Metzler, Miriam Voran, Don Weaver