2011
More than 25% of the class of 2011 signed letters of intent to continue playing athletics at the college level.
| Jenae Hershberger | Cross Country | Hesston College |
| Elyse Hooley | Soccer | Hesston College |
| Seth Krabill | Tennis | Goshen College |
| Mattie Lehman | Volleyball | Eastern Mennonite University |
| Ben Mast | Volleyball | Eastern Mennonite University |
| Mandy Schlabach | Volleyball | Goshen College |
| Heather Schwartz | Soccer | Hesston College |
| Aaron Stiffney | Soccer | Goshen College |
| Joel Yoder | Soccer | Goshen College |
| Sharisse Yoder | Soccer | Marian University |
| Marla zumFelde | Basketball | Eastern Mennonite University |
