| 1978 | Watercolor | Terri Anne Stern | Senior |
| 1979 | Copper Tooling | Peggy Schrock | Sophomore |
| 1980 | Eggshell Mosaic | Peggy Schrock | Junior |
| 1981 | Acrylic Painting | Roz Brenneman | Senior |
| 1982 | Sand Painting | Troy Risser | Freshman |
| 1983 | Acrylic Painting | Jerrol Shaum | Junior |
| 1984 | Airbrush | Jerrol Shaum | Senior |
| 1985 | Copper Tooling | Colleen Schleining | Freshman |
| 1986 | Ink Drawing | Sheila McElmurry | Junior |
| 1987 | Acrylic Painting | Dawn Hochstetler | Senior |
| 1988 | Batik | Gretchen Nyce | Junior |
| 1989 | Ink Drawing | Nina Bailey | Freshman |
| 1990 | Linocut | Cheryl Hochstetler | Senior |
| 1991 | Copper Tooling | Darryl Eichorn | Senior |
| 1993 | Ceramic Vase | Tammy Sawatzky | Junior |
| 1994 | Acrylic Painting | Sarah Kingsley | Senior |
| 1995 | Midnight Flight | Crystal Rogers | Senior |
| 1996 | 3-D
Sculpture: Jesus on the Cross |
Ben Hartman | Junior |
| 1997 | Steel Sculpture | Greg Stahly | Senior |
| 1998 | Charcoal Drawings | Rachel Paulovich | Senior |
| 1999 | Painting: Anne Frank | Brenda Harley | Senior |
| 2000 | Photography:
Photos of Hands |
Renee Glick | Senior |